A Game a Week #5: Return of the Obra Dinn

Return of the Obra Dinn is a really interesting game. It’s one of those indie titles that has built up quite a reputation, and having finally played it, I can understand why. It’s a fairly unique experience, built around a simple premise: investigate a ship that has returned to port with its entire crew missing or dead, and work out what happened to everyone aboard.
Armed with a mysterious pocket watch and a journal, you can revisit the moments surrounding each crew member’s death, piecing together what happened and identifying the people involved. There’s no elaborate combat system, no skill trees or particularly complex mechanics. The entire experience revolves around observation, deduction and putting together a rather complicated puzzle.

I’ll admit, I found the process a little repetitive at times. A lot of the gameplay involves moving sequentially through these little snapshots of the past, searching each scene for enough information to start connecting names, faces and events. I occasionally found myself wanting to get on with it, rather than methodically working through every available moment until I had enough clues to make progress. Some of the interactions also felt a little clunky, particularly waiting for the trail indicator to slowly guide you towards the next body. It can be a surprisingly long-winded process when you’re eager to move on. And then on the flip side, some snapshots were super busy and the game would try close the snapshot and transition out earlier than when you were ready. It didn't affect much of the progression but was a repeated minor inconvenience for me.
That said, there’s something genuinely compelling about how the game structures its mystery.
Rather than relying on conventional progression systems, the game uses information as its primary reward. Every new scene gives you another piece of the puzzle. You might discover a character’s name, learn about a relationship, witness an unexpected event or uncover a small detail that makes an earlier scene suddenly make sense. You’re constantly being fed information, but rarely given the complete picture.
And that’s really what keeps you playing. You want to know what happened.
There are several little stories unfolding throughout the ship, each with their own characters, relationships and tragic outcomes. Some are relatively straightforward, while others are much harder to piece together. As you start connecting these individual stories, you gradually develop an understanding of the wider events that took place aboard the Obra Dinn.

It’s particularly satisfying when you finally identify someone or work out how a particular sequence of events unfolded. You feel genuinely clever, even though the game has technically given you everything you need to reach the conclusion. It’s a great example of making the player feel like they’ve made a discovery rather than simply being told something through dialogue or exposition.
I also really enjoyed the way the game presents its story. Despite everything being delivered through static scenes, there are some fantastic moments of spectacle. Certain deaths are particularly elaborate, bizarre or downright funny, and there’s a strange sense of whimsy running through what is otherwise a pretty horrific series of events. You’re investigating a ship full of people who have endured an absolutely horrendous ordeal, but some of the individual stories are genuinely entertaining in their own dark way.
The mysterious, almost Lovecraftian elements surrounding the ship also give everything a distinctive atmosphere. There’s a lot of intrigue around exactly what happened, and the game’s unusual visual style does a great job of reinforcing that feeling. It’s a very memorable presentation, especially for a game that achieves so much with relatively little.
I played through it alongside my partner, which I think added quite a lot to the experience. Having someone else to bounce ideas off, compare observations with and work through the various mysteries made the deduction side of things particularly enjoyable. It’s the sort of game where two people looking at the same scene can notice completely different details, and that makes solving things together really rewarding.
MINOR SPOILER WARNING*
There were a couple of moments where I probably wasn’t as observant as I could have been, too. One particular mystery involving the survivors escaping the ship had me scratching my head for a while. I hadn’t initially realised that the person who sent you the journal was actually Henry Evans, one of the crew members who had managed to escape. His letter gives you a clue about where he went, but because I hadn’t made that connection, I spent far too long trying to work out where everyone had disappeared to. I eventually finished the game without solving it, only to realise afterwards how obvious the answer was once I understood who had sent the letter.
I think that’s part of the appeal, though. Obra Dinn rewards players who pay attention, remember small details and are willing to revisit information they’ve previously overlooked. Some of the connections are subtle, and the satisfaction comes from making those connections yourself.
Ultimately, I think it’s a really well-made and genuinely unique game. It doesn’t need elaborate systems or complex mechanics because the structure of its narrative does all the heavy lifting. The constant drip-feed of information, the interconnected little stories and the satisfaction of gradually understanding what happened are enough to keep you engaged.

I wouldn’t say I was completely hooked throughout. There were definitely moments where I found the process a little repetitive and wanted the game to get out of its own way. But the overall experience is something quite special. It’s a clever mystery with a fantastic presentation, some wonderfully bizarre stories and a really satisfying approach to player-driven discovery.
It’s easy to see why Return of the Obra Dinn has become such a beloved indie game. A simple premise, a distinctive identity and a really clever way of making the player do the storytelling for themselves. A worthwhile experience, and a good reminder that you don’t always need complicated gameplay systems to create something memorable.




Comments